23 of the Best True Crime Audiobooks to Keep You Up at Night

Audiobook list · Updated November 2026

23 of the Best True Crime Audiobooks to Keep You Up at Night

True crime reminds us that the real world can be more unsettling than any novel, and it suits audio, because a good narrator makes you feel like you are sitting across from the investigator. Each pick below is recommended by an independent bookseller through Libro.fm.

Every pick has the narrator and length of the edition I link to, plus the bookseller’s own review of why it’s worth your time. A heads-up: some of these stories deal with violence and abuse.

By Peter Clemens · Originally published April 2022 · Updated November 2026

Some links are affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no cost to you. How I make money.

If you only listen to three

A cold-case obsession, a historical conspiracy and a heist you can finish in a day.

  1. I’ll Be Gone in the DarkMichelle McNamara’s hunt for the Golden State Killer, 10h 7m
    See it ↓
  2. Killers of the Flower MoonA chilling 1920s conspiracy, read by Will Patton and a full cast
    See it ↓
  3. The Art ThiefA short, gripping heist story with no violence, 5h 39m
    See it ↓
Why Libro.fm? It splits its profits with independent bookstores, so your purchase supports a bookshop. Read my Libro.fm review.See Libro.fm

Jump to a style

History’s Most Notorious Cases

Landmark crimes and the eras they shook, told by writers who dig deep.

Cover of the The Devil in the White City audiobook by Erik Larson
Best for history lovers

The Devil in the White City

by Erik Larson
Read by Scott BrickLength 15h 0m

“The whole time I was listening to this, I kept asking myself whether it was, in fact, nonfiction. Erik Larson’s ability to spin a true tale will have you saying, “This can’t be a true story.” I’ve since seen that he often includes an author’s note, assuring readers that he’s telling you a true story.”

Cover of the Killers of the Flower Moon audiobook by David Grann
Best investigative history

Killers of the Flower Moon

by David Grann
Read by Will Patton, Ann Marie Lee & Danny CampbellLength 9h 4m

“One of the most horrific chapters in American history is brought back to the national consciousness with alarming detail in Killers of the Flower Moon. After the Osage Indian Nation strikes oil, its members become rich beyond their wildest dreams, only to encounter a vast and murderous conspiracy that will leave more than 60 members of the nation dead.

Keep reading

David Grann reconstructs those murders and the subsequent investigations with astonishing care and reveals the depths of a conspiracy that stretched from Oklahoma to Washington, D.C.”

Cover of the The Ghosts of Eden Park audiobook by Karen Abbott
Best Prohibition-era story

The Ghosts of Eden Park

by Karen Abbott
Read by Rob Shapiro & Cassandra CampbellLength 11h 12m

“This true crime story reads like a great murder mystery and will have you hooked from the start. Wonderful research pulls you right into the story, in which readers are introduced to George Remus, a bootlegging lawyer/millionaire during the prohibition Jazz Age, and Mabel Walker Willebrandt, who is given the job of prosecutor because the corrupt U.S.

Keep reading

Attorney’s office doesn’t think she will pose a threat to their relationship with Remus. Willebrandt will prove them wrong. The tension, greed, and flair of The Ghosts of Eden Park makes this the best nonfiction book of the summer!”

Cover of the The Trial of Lizzie Borden audiobook by Cara Robertson
Best courtroom drama

The Trial of Lizzie Borden

by Cara Robertson
Read by Amanda CarlinLength 11h 47m

“Cara Robertson’s first book details the events surrounding the infamous murders of Andrew and Abby Borden in Fall River, Massachusetts in 1892. Based entirely on primary sources: trial transcripts, contemporary accounts, and even recently discovered letters from Lizzie herself, The Trial of Lizzie Borden is an in-depth discussion of the circumstances surrounding the incident and Lizzie’s subsequent trial.

Keep reading

Robertson has poured decades of research into this sensational book, breathing new life into a story that has captivated the American psyche for over a century.”

Cover of the Under the Banner of Heaven audiobook by Jon Krakauer
Best on faith and violence

Under the Banner of Heaven

by Jon Krakauer
Read by Scott BrickLength 12h 32m

“So often it seems that people approach events like these wondering how someone could possibly do something so terrible. Jon Krakauer bypasses the ‘how’ and goes immediately for the ‘why.’ With a keen eye for discrepancies and Scott Brick’s intense narration for the audiobook, Krakauer leaves no stone unturned when it comes to detailing what led to the Lafferty murders through historical, social, and familial contexts.

Keep reading

Under the Banner of Heaven is a severe breakdown of how religious fervor works, how zealotry can build up speed a lot faster than you think it will, and what environments serve to make or break any grassroots religion.”

Cover of the The Wager audiobook by David Grann
Best survival story

The Wager

by David Grann
Read by Dion Graham & David GrannLength 8h 28m

“Gripping and thrilling, this story dives into the making of a mutinous voyage that inspired adventurers and authors for centuries to follow. Spanning the course of several decades, Grann’s ability to blend handwritten accounts and perspectives of a handful of men in order to paint a complete picture of a historical shipwreck & the ensuing mutiny is unparalleled.

Keep reading

When circumstances become dire, at what point does the captain’s authority no longer hold water? When does the strength of the empire that upholds law and order begin to weaken? The moral quandaries that are brought to light during such a survival situation come out in full force in this book, and I would recommend this to anyone who is interested in a page-turning account of a tragic non-fiction adventure.”

Investigations and Cold Cases

Obsessive research, unsolved questions and the people who refuse to let go.

Cover of the I’ll Be Gone in the Dark audiobook by Michelle McNamara
Best for armchair detectives

I’ll Be Gone in the Dark

by Michelle McNamara
Read by Gabra Zackman, Gillian Flynn & Patton OswaltLength 10h 7m

“An overwhelmingly obsessed Michelle McNamara dissects the decades old trail of tragedy, trauma and ongoing taunts by the elusive East Area Rapist in her investigative crime thriller “I’ll Be Gone in the Dark” published posthumously after her unexpected demise.

Keep reading

Dubbed the “Golden State Killer” by McNamara herself, his crime spree started with 50 unsolved rapes before escalating to numerous murders leaving terrorized California residents tense for ten years. A determined McNamara meticulously researches this reign of terror with such precision it’s sure to pry this perpetrators identity out of obscurity and into justice, a suitable ending for this authors’ life.”

Cover of the We Keep the Dead Close audiobook by Becky Cooper
Best for cold-case fans

We Keep the Dead Close

by Becky Cooper
Read by Becky CooperLength 15h 47m

“As much a journey for the writer as it is for the reader, this book solves a murder but leaves us with many unanswered questions. We Keep the Dead Close challenges us to question our assumptions as well as the paths we use to arrive at those assumptions.

Keep reading

Delving into the academic culture of Harvard, the misogyny of the 1960s, and the burgeoning women’s rights movement, the story follows several threads, all of which have a significant impact on the life of Jane Britton, whose story is told with empathy, compassion, and five decades of curiosity.”

Cover of the The Third Rainbow Girl audiobook by Emma Copley Eisenberg
Best Appalachian true crime

The Third Rainbow Girl

by Emma Copley Eisenberg
Read by Emma Copley EisenbergLength 10h 33m

“The facts are that in the summer of 1980, two young women were hitchhiking in Pocahontas County, West Virginia en route to the annual Rainbow Festival. Their murdered bodies were found in a remote clearing on a remote road.

Keep reading

Over the years, multiple people confessed to the murders. Was it a local as many thought? Or an itinerant mass murderer traveling the country, raging against blacks and others? Eisenberg dives deeply into the case after spending time there years later as a Vista volunteer. This engaging book tells the story of the people of this rural county, the history of the area, and the officials who would not let the case die. It is also Emma’s story: her time with these people, her loves, and her discontent. It is a stirring addition to the Appalachian story.”

Cover of the Furious Hours audiobook by Casey Cep
Best for literary true crime

Furious Hours

by Casey Cep
Read by Hillary HuberLength 11h 15m

“In Cold Blood and To Kill a Mockingbird kept me up reading all night as a teen, and I can now add Furious Hours to the list of couldn’t-put-it-down tomes. I was enthralled, educated, and awestruck by Casey Cep’s well-researched and masterfully written true-crime account of a rural minister, his lawyer, and his killer.

Keep reading

Thankfully, Cep discovered and brought to light what surely could have been Harper Lee’s second bestseller. Now…off to get a good night’s rest!”

Cover of the Say Nothing audiobook by Patrick Radden Keefe
Best for modern history fans

Say Nothing

by Patrick Radden Keefe
Read by Matthew BlaneyLength 14h 40m

“Say Nothing is a chilling chronicle of The Troubles of Northern Ireland and its aftermath, with special focus on the orchestrated disappearance of civilian mother of ten Jean McConville. Per the author, Patrick Radden Keefe, the book is not a comprehensive history, but as someone who knew virtually nothing about The Troubles going in, I found Say Nothing to be a great place to start.

Keep reading

I found the account of the Price sisters to be particularly fascinating. This is a compelling story about people standing up for what they believe in, filled with betrayal and deadly consequences. Matthew Blaney’s narration is exquisite.”

Cover of the Ghettoside audiobook by Jill Leovy
Best investigative journalism

Ghettoside

by Jill Leovy
Read by Rebecca LowmanLength 13h 24m

“For over a decade Leovy has reported on murder in L.A., especially on the killing of black men (and boys) by black men (and boys) in the south side of the city, and in Ghettoside she does justice to a vast and varied range of characters: victims (often chosen nearly at random), killers (often motivated by revenge), witnesses (often terrified and reluctant), and especially the few dogged homicide detectives who refuse to shrug and let murders go unsolved.

Keep reading

And from this daily tragedy she builds a compelling conclusion: that black-on-black homicide flourishes because it is not punished; while the law harasses African Americans over pretexts and petty crimes, it declines to protect them from the worst crime of all. It’s a complex, subtly skillful, and necessary book.”

Cover of the Yellow Bird audiobook by Sierra Crane Murdoch
Best true crime thriller

Yellow Bird

by Sierra Crane Murdoch
Read by Sierra Crane MurdochLength 14h 56m

“Iconic, complicated, bad-ass women, we love: Norma Rae, Karen Silkwood, Erin Brokovich, and now Lissa Yellow Bird. My husband and I listened to journalist and author Sierra Crane Murdoch tell the story of Lissa Yellow Bird and her search for justice, as we traveled through the Dakotas, passing by places named in this true crime thriller.

Keep reading

I can’t imagine a better story for this part of the country. It is a journalistic story about fracking, boom times, corporate greed, tribal politics, intergenerational trauma, family, community, race, oh, and there is a murder and then another. Lissa Yellow Bird, who leads a one-woman search for a missing trucker, is one of the most complex heroines you’ll ever meet. Sierra Crane Murdoch spent eight years researching, interviewing, combing through files, spending time with Lissa and her family, and writing, and it shows in every carefully thought-out chapter.”

Heists, Cons and Capers

True crime with no body count, and plenty of nerve.

Cover of the The Art Thief audiobook by Michael Finkel
Best short listen

The Art Thief

by Michael Finkel
Read by Edoardo Ballerini & Michael FinkelLength 5h 39m

“I was there, in the room, jaw agape, with the most successful art thief in history as he did the deed, time and time again. In The Art Thief: A True Story of Love, Crime and a Dangerous Obsession, author Michael Finkel describes in astounding detail how Stéphane Breitwieser made off with artworks valued in the billions of dollars.

Keep reading

Finkel’s years of research resulted in a mesmerizing portrait of a young man driven to steal by elusive motivations. An incredible account of a fascinating and infuriating individual.”

Cover of the The Feather Thief audiobook by Kirk Wallace Johnson
Best stranger-than-fiction heist

The Feather Thief

by Kirk Wallace Johnson
Read by MacLeod AndrewsLength 8h 4m

“The Feather Thief is true crime at its best — a tale starting with the Amazonian explorations of Darwin-era naturalists, rooted in the eccentric sensibilities of Victorian collectors, fueled by the obscure cult of fly-fishing tying, and culminating with a shocking 2009 British Museum heist by a shy American flautist.

Keep reading

All of these elements are deftly brought together at a thriller’s pace by author Kirk Johnson, a veteran of the Iraqi reconstruction effort suffering from PTSD, who stumbles across the story while fly-fishing in New Mexico in 2011. I mean, you can’t make this stuff up.”

Cover of the The Falcon Thief audiobook by Joshua Hammer
Best wildlife crime

The Falcon Thief

by Joshua Hammer
Read by Matthew Lloyd DaviesLength 8h 23m

“Jeffrey Lendrum is a criminal extraordinaire who grew up in South Africa, honing not only his love of birds but his heists—stealing the eggs of rare birds of prey to sell to egg collectors around the world.

Keep reading

Soon he was selling falcon eggs to Middle Eastern buyers where falcon racing is a multimillion dollar business and one egg can sell for thousands. Detective Andy McWilliam with the UK’s National Wildlife Crime Unit is determined to stop Lendrum and protect the world’s birds of prey. This true crime story has it all: mystery, adventure, and danger, making for a great read from start to finish.”

Bookseller pick: Sandi, Brilliant Books Audio
Cover of the The Great Pretender audiobook by Susannah Cahalan
Best for psychology fans

The Great Pretender

by Susannah Cahalan
Read by Christie Moreau & Susannah CahalanLength 11h 3m

“Susannah Cahalan, the bestselling author of Brain on Fire, is back with another riveting true story of madness and the mental health system. In the 1970s, Dr. David Rosenhan convinced seven sane people to join him in committing themselves to mental hospitals as patients and trying to get out on their own.

Keep reading

What begins as an inspiring and daring story of experimentation darkens and twists as Cahalan closes in on a story shrouded in mystery—who were these seven ‘pseudopatients’ in Rosenhan’s groundbreaking study, and what really happened to them? The Great Pretender is not-to-be-missed narrative nonfiction.”

Power, Corruption and Cover-ups

Crimes committed in boardrooms, newsrooms and hospitals.

Cover of the Empire of Pain audiobook by Patrick Radden Keefe
Best on corporate crime

Empire of Pain

by Patrick Radden Keefe
Read by Patrick Radden KeefeLength 18h 6m

“Another major hit by Patrick Radden Keefe, one of the best journalists working today. This is the story of the Sackler family—the ones behind Oxycontin, and thus the opiod crisis. The book shows how the family founders went from small pharmaceutical company owners to one of the biggest in the country, to then the harbingers of doom in their flagship drug, Oxycontin.

Keep reading

It shows how they pushed it to market, encouraged its sales with dodgy tactics, and knowingly ignored its addictive properties to make a profit, driving America into our largest epidemic to date. You likely know some of this story. Trust me, you want the full one.”

Cover of the Catch and Kill audiobook by Ronan Farrow
Best investigative thriller

Catch and Kill

by Ronan Farrow
Read by Ronan FarrowLength 10h 43m

“A timely, incredibly important account of the difficulties Farrow faced at NBC while working on the Weinstein expose, which he took to the New Yorker and subsequently won a Pulitzer for. The audiobook is grippingly read by Farrow (though the accents he attempts are… let’s go with ‘confusing’).

Keep reading

It’s upsetting, sure, but heartening to see the exhaustive research and the very clearly laid-out account of how Farrow had to work against the very powerful high-profile members of the media establishment—including his own bosses—not only because of Weinstein’s well-oiled intimidation machine but also as part of those figures attempting to cover up their own histories of being harassers. Highly recommend this important piece of current events journalism, which reads like a thriller novel.”

Cover of the Five Days at Memorial audiobook by Sheri Fink
Best for medical ethics debates

Five Days at Memorial

by Sheri Fink
Read by Kirsten PotterLength 17h 33m

“In the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina, Memorial Hospital became known as the hospital that euthanized patients during the flood. The truth, however, is infinitely more complicated than that, and in this brilliant, completely engrossing book, Sheri Fink tells the whole story from every angle she can. This book sucked me in, didn’t let go, and left me stunned. I cannot recommend it highly enough.”

True Crime Memoirs

Personal stories where the crime is part of the writer’s own life.

Cover of the Memorial Drive audiobook by Natasha Trethewey
Best memoir, read by the author

Memorial Drive

by Natasha Trethewey
Read by Natasha TretheweyLength 5h 9m

“This is one of those “I’m changed forever” books and having the author, poet Natasha Trethewey read it makes it reverberate in the soul even more. The writing of this memoir is exquisite and the construction of the prose is perfect. The heartbreak and honesty of the author will stay with me. I can’t wait to hear back from those I’ve recommended it to, they’re in for a special experience.”

Cover of the Nowhere Girl audiobook by Cheryl Diamond
Best family-on-the-run story

Nowhere Girl

by Cheryl Diamond
Read by Eileen StevensLength 10h 37m

“In this riveting memoir, Cheryl (a.k.a. Crystal a.k.a. Harbhajan) recounts her childhood growing up on the run, crisscrossing the globe with her family in order to evade Interpol. Diamond’s childhood set the stage for an extremely dysfunctional adolescence thanks to her charming yet intensely controlling father.

Keep reading

Not only was the family on the run, they were living by his set of rules and principles that set them even further apart from regular society. Nowhere Girl hit exactly the way I think the best memoirs do: a place that is stranger-than-fiction and incredibly heartfelt. On top of that, Diamond is an excellent writer, evoking a strong sense of place in each setting as well as offering insightful commentary on her emotional state along the journey. Eileen Stevens narrates phenomenally, making it a slam dunk audiobook choice.”

Cover of the The Fact of a Body audiobook by Alex Marzano-Lesnevich
Best genre-bending memoir

The Fact of a Body

by Alex Marzano-Lesnevich
Read by Alex Marzano-LesnevichLength 10h 38m

“Alexandria Marzano-Lesnevich didn’t set out to investigate murder of six-year-old Jeremy Guillory in Louisiana; it was the case she happened upon as a young law school intern in 1992. In a fascinating twist, this becomes not only the true story of a heinous crime for which the perpetrator is in prison, but also of the investigation that unlocks the author’s memories of her own youth, a childhood in which she and her sisters were repeatedly sexually abused by their maternal grandfather.

Keep reading

As Marzano-Lesnevich moves backward and forward in time between the young man who killed Jeremy and her own life, the reader is swept along on a current of dismay and awe: dismay that human beings can do these things to each other, and awe that the author could face such demons and move on. I’ve never read another book like this.”

True crime audiobooks: common questions

What is the best true crime audiobook for beginners?

Start with I’ll Be Gone in the Dark, Killers of the Flower Moon or The Art Thief. All three are well paced, beautifully read and easy to follow even if you have never listened to true crime before.

What are the best true crime audiobooks for a long drive?

Empire of Pain (18h 6m), Five Days at Memorial (17h 33m), We Keep the Dead Close (15h 47m) and The Devil in the White City (15h 0m) will each fill a road trip.

What is the shortest true crime audiobook on this list?

Memorial Drive is the shortest at 5h 9m, followed by The Art Thief at 5h 39m and The Feather Thief at 8h 4m.

Are there true crime audiobooks without murder?

Yes. The Art Thief, The Feather Thief, The Falcon Thief and The Great Pretender are all real-life crime stories built around theft and deception rather than killing.

Which true crime audiobooks are read by the author?

We Keep the Dead Close, The Third Rainbow Girl, Empire of Pain, Catch and Kill, Yellow Bird and Memorial Drive are all narrated by their authors.

Where can I listen to these audiobooks?

Every pick links to Libro.fm, where your purchase supports an independent bookstore. You can also borrow many audiobooks for free through your library with the Libby app.

More audiobook recommendations

Never run out of audiobooks to listen to

One email a week: the best current audiobook deals and one editor’s pick.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *