24 of the Best Mystery Audiobooks to Keep You Guessing

Audiobook list · Updated November 2026

24 of the Best Mystery Audiobooks to Keep You Guessing

Mystery audiobooks are made for listening, because a good narrator draws you into the investigation and keeps you guessing. Each pick below is recommended by an independent bookseller through Libro.fm.

Every pick has the narrator and length of the edition I link to, plus the bookseller’s own review of why it’s worth your time. Want more suspense and less sleuthing? See my best thriller audiobooks.

By Peter Clemens · Originally published March 2023 · Updated November 2026

Some links are affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no cost to you. How I make money.

If you only listen to three

A cozy favorite, a clever modern puzzle and an Agatha Christie classic.

  1. The Thursday Murder ClubRetirement-home sleuths, read by Lesley Manville
    See it ↓
  2. Everyone in My Family Has Killed SomeoneA clever family mystery, read by Barton Welch
    See it ↓
  3. And Then There Were NoneThe Agatha Christie classic, read by Hugh Fraser
    See it ↓
Why Libro.fm? It splits its profits with independent bookstores, so your purchase supports a bookshop. Read my Libro.fm review.See Libro.fm

Jump to a style

Cozy and funny mysteries

Light, witty and full of charming amateur sleuths.

Cover of the The Thursday Murder Club audiobook by Richard Osman
Best cozy starting point

The Thursday Murder Club

by Richard Osman
Read by Lesley ManvilleLength 12h 26m

“Witty and sharp and twisty, this mystery will be just your cup of tea! At a posh retirement community, an elderly group of crime enthusiasts meet on Thursdays to go over old cold cases. When several current murders happen practically on their front stoop, these silver haired sleuths start digging for clues.

Keep reading

There are a lot of secrets and hidden motives to unearth, which will keep the reader guessing until the last page. The narration by Lesley Manville is superb!”

Cover of the We Solve Murders audiobook by Richard Osman
Best for sharp banter

We Solve Murders

by Richard Osman
Read by Nicola WalkerLength 10h 32m

“Murder shouldn’t be this fun! Fast paced with engaging characters and laugh out loud dialogue. Highly recommend.”

Cover of the Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers audiobook by Jesse Q. Sutanto
Best wholesome-meets-murder

Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers

by Jesse Q. Sutanto
Read by Eunice WongLength 10h 41m

“In true Jesse Q. Sutanto fashion, her newest book brings lovable characters, hijinks, and a rollicking good time. I don’t know how she makes murder so wholesome and funny but she does in a forget-your-worries-and-only-read-this-book way every time.”

Cover of the Finlay Donovan Is Killing It audiobook by Elle Cosimano
Best quick, funny listen

Finlay Donovan Is Killing It

by Elle Cosimano
Read by Angela DaweLength 9h 59m

“Looking for a mystery that’s funny and filled with girl power? This book is for you. A quick, fun read.”

Cover of the The Golden Spoon audiobook by Jessa Maxwell
Best for baking show fans

The Golden Spoon

by Jessa Maxwell
Read by Full castLength 8h 37m

“A surprising and delightful combination of Agatha Christie and The Great British Baking Show, The Golden Spoon will sweep you off your feet and into a world of cakes, pies and gruesome murders! When six amateur bakers show up at Grafton Manor to compete on Bake Week, the long running television baking show, the well planned competition quickly falls apart, with sabotage and eventually murder making their way onto the menu.

Keep reading

The Martha Stewart-esque judge and the handsome but calculating cohost make for a fake baking show you wish you could actually watch. I did not expect it to be such a page turner, but both the pacing and the twisting plot kept me riveted from beginning to end. A great book for mystery lovers and people who spend too much time watching Paul Hollywood crush dreams.”

Cover of the Three Bags Full audiobook by Leonie Swann
Best unusual detectives

Three Bags Full

by Leonie Swann
Read by Caroline LennonLength 12h 37m

“Wise, witty, and wonderful! Exactly the right story for exactly the right time, this clever and philosophical novel is absolutely charming and a decent mystery. I am more grateful than ever that I don’t like lamb.”

Classic whodunits and locked circles

Remote locations, a cast of suspects and a killer to find.

Cover of the And Then There Were None audiobook by Agatha Christie
Best classic whodunit

And Then There Were None

by Agatha Christie
Read by Hugh FraserLength 5h 36m

“From the queen of mysteries comes the inspiration for all of your favorite modern-day remote-location murder mysteries. Ten seemingly unconnected strangers arrive at a remote private island owned by an anonymous millionaire, where they all begin to be murdered one by one. And Then There Were None is perfect for those who dream of donning a Holmesian detective cap and who perhaps enjoy playing Clue a little too much.”

Cover of the Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel audiobook by Lucy Foley & Agatha Christie
Best for Agatha Christie fans

Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel

by Lucy Foley & Agatha Christie
Read by Full castLength 9h 14m

“What fun! I felt like I was discovering Agatha Christie all over again as I listened to this intriguing, locked room mystery set in an elegant alpine hotel in Switzerland not long after the war. The setting, the characters, and the dialogue were perfect, and Miss Marple was as smart and loveable as ever. Lucy Foley did a fabulous job.”

Cover of the Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone audiobook by Benjamin Stevenson
Best family-secrets mystery

Everyone in My Family Has Killed Someone

by Benjamin Stevenson
Read by Barton WelchLength 9h 30m

“Being such an avid Mystery/Thriller reader, I am always trying to figure out the twists and turns of a story before the main character is able to solve it- and I’m usually pretty spot on. This book, however, was a breath of fresh air- a clever, surprisingly deep mystery that kept me on my toes throughout, even though the self-proclaimed ‘reliable narrator’ Ernie was very forthcoming with every piece of evidence and his deductions throughout the story.

Keep reading

Even though there’s a lot of death and suspense, at the heart of this story is a complex family that’s trying to come together to defy their generational curses, even though the odds are stacked against them (and some members are stacked against each other). I loved listening to this story, not only because of the dreamy Australian accent, but also because the tone made me feel like I was in on the investigation- Stevenson’s writing and approach to turning tried and true mystery tropes on their head has definitely made him a must-read author for me!”

Cover of the Everyone on This Train Is a Suspect audiobook by Benjamin Stevenson
Best train mystery

Everyone on This Train Is a Suspect

by Benjamin Stevenson
Read by Barton Welch & Megan SmartLength 8h 27m

“This mystery was an absolute delight. I listened to it and flew through, it was so good. And, it turns out it was the second book in the series and I got to enjoy it even without reading the first. (Which I have now listened to and also loved.) Ernest Cunningham, writer of how-to write mystery books, is on a super special writer’s society train ride when he is, again, beset by murder.

Keep reading

Using the tactics he’s learned from the writers during the golden age of mystery, he is the only one who can solve it! This tongue-in-cheek, well-crafted, and hilarious mystery is one of my favorites of the year.”

Cover of the The Guest List audiobook by Lucy Foley
Best island mystery

The Guest List

by Lucy Foley
Read by Full castLength 10h 22m

“This was a great, suspenseful listen. It wasn’t as spooky as I’d been hoping for, but it was an excellent mystery. The story takes place on an island off of Ireland with an old manor house that is hosting a posh wedding.

Keep reading

The story starts the day before the murder and ends with the body being found. We get the viewpoint of several of the guests and the bride as the story builds up to the murder. By the time it happens there are numerous people who would want the victim dead (and you will too). A very original, very well written mystery.”

Cover of the The Villa audiobook by Rachel Hawkins
Best dual-timeline mystery

The Villa

by Rachel Hawkins
Read by Julia Whelan, Kimberly M. Wetherell & Shiromi ArserioLength 8h 38m

“I love it when I think an author has revealed all the juicy plot twists and I have figured out where the story is headed and solved the mystery, only to be surprised by more tantalizing twists and even more mysteries.

Keep reading

Welcome to The Villa! Two lifelong friends, now both successful authors, head to Italy for a summer at a beautiful villa. As it turns out, the villa is famous for having been the scene of the murder of a young rock musician in 1974. Drawn into the story of that fateful summer, Emily begins to research. Clues she finds lead her on a path neither she nor her friend Chess expected for their summer, much as the group in 1974 did not expect the ending to their vacation. Unfolding in alternating chapters, the stories of the 1974 summer and this summer intertwine and twist in marvelously unexpected ways.”

Twisty modern puzzles

Stories told through podcasts, transcripts, case files and nested manuscripts.

Cover of the The Woman in the Library audiobook by Sulari Gentill
Best mystery within a mystery

The Woman in the Library

by Sulari Gentill
Read by Katherine LittrellLength 8h 58m

“I’d never thought of the term metafiction before, but in The Woman in the Library, Australian writer Sulari Gentill dives right into a recursive story of a writer, Hannah, writing a book about a writer, Winifred, who is writing a book and during a research trip to the Boston Public Library, becomes enmeshed in a murder investigation, using the people she encounters in her book.

Keep reading

And then there’s Leo, who Hannah is emailing chapters of the book to for comments. When Leo’s feedback becomes creepier and weirder, his story and the fictional mystery start to parallel each other, including a character also named Leo in Winifred’s story. Murders in two realities in one book; so intelligent and well constructed!”

Cover of the The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels audiobook by Janice Hallett
Best told in transcripts

The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels

by Janice Hallett
Read by Full castLength 10h 31m

“Sometimes you just need a twisting, British-set mystery — this is the perfect book for that reading mood! It unfolds in layers, told through transcripts and messages, raising questions to the very riveting end.”

Cover of the Listen for the Lie audiobook by Amy Tintera
Best for true-crime podcast fans

Listen for the Lie

by Amy Tintera
Read by January LaVoy & Will DamronLength 9h 18m

“Where are my true-crime-podcast junkies at? You’re lying to yourself if this book doesn’t intrigue you. Then again, they say the truth doesn’t matter. Tintera deftly doles out information in this small-town whodunnit that’s anything but cozy.

Keep reading

Our could-be-murderer and unreliable narrator Lucy charmed me with her gallows humor and unapologetic bluntness; I frequently cackled out loud and stayed up way too late to finish. A twisted, dark delight.”

Cover of the A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder audiobook by Holly Jackson
Best full-cast mystery

A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder

by Holly Jackson
Read by Full castLength 10h 53m

“CHILLS. This book was AMAZING. Experiencing the twists and turns of this case along side Pip and taking risks along side of her sucked me into the audiobook. I particularly enjoyed how all of her logs, interviews, and case notes were laid out throughout the story.

Keep reading

Each interview sounded like something straight from a true-crime documentary. Pip was relentless in her pursuit of the truth, and the ending had me gasping and on the edge of my seat.”

Detectives and small-town secrets

Seasoned investigators and towns that keep their secrets.

Cover of the The Searcher audiobook by Tana French
Best rural Ireland atmosphere

The Searcher

by Tana French
Read by Roger ClarkLength 14h 32m

“This series is a new favorite for me and my top audiobook of the year. Such a fun and gritty contemporary western with the crusty old cop and the young angry teen. I loved Cal and Trey’s friendship and the rural Ireland setting that came to life with the accents in the audiobook. Do not miss the next two books in the series – it only gets better!!!”

Cover of the The Dry audiobook by Jane Harper
Best Australian outback mystery

The Dry

by Jane Harper
Read by Stephen ShanahanLength 10h 1m

“This story of a small town and the secrets it has been protecting for decades is fast-paced and never predictable. In a remote section of rural Australia during an extended drought, devastating weather conditions collide with an unexpected turn of events that ultimately results in the murder of a young family.

Keep reading

Bearing the scars of the town’s past, Aaron Falk returns home for the funeral and is forced to make a choice between saving himself and facing a secret he has been hiding from for 20 years. This is an amazing debut that I could not put down!”

Cover of the Miss Wolcott’s Ghost audiobook by Louise Penny
Best new Gamache mystery

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost

by Louise Penny
Read by Alfred MolinaLength 13h 42m

“I always read and love Penny’s Gamache series and, happily, this one signals a return to the spirit and depth of the series’s origins, where the last previous few have lost a bit of that marvelous spark.

Keep reading

If you’ve been a fan from the start, you will love this one. It begins when Chief Inspector Gamache receives a mysterious, brief call in the middle of the night about a body found in “Lost Nation.” What body? Where is Lost Nation? Who was the caller? Gamache and his team unravel a crime that has tendrils reaching like vines into the past and the present, across the sea about back again. The audiobook was a great listen and included some well-placed dramatic flourishes.”

Literary and imaginative mysteries

Dark academia, Victorian ghosts and a fantasy murder case.

Cover of the The Tainted Cup audiobook by Robert Jackson Bennett
Best fantasy mystery

The Tainted Cup

by Robert Jackson Bennett
Read by Andrew FallaizeLength 13h 51m

“A Sherlock and Watson style mystery with the futuristic enhancements of the Hunger Games and the walled city politics of Attack on Titan. Fiendishly clever and witty, this was a lot of fun. Andrew Fallaize did an incredible job creating the perfect voices for all the eclectic characters. Highly Recommended!”

Cover of the If We Were Villains audiobook by M. L. Rio
Best dark academia

If We Were Villains

by M. L. Rio
Read by Robert PetkoffLength 12h 50m

“Each year, when Fall finally comes around, I find myself wanting to revisit this book. Seven thespians studying Shakespeare, a murder, and the dark academia genre that has become so very popular these days. What more could you ask for in a book?”

Cover of the The Secret History audiobook by Donna Tartt
Best read by the author

The Secret History

by Donna Tartt
Read by Donna TarttLength 22h 3m

“This novel is the Holy Bible of Dark Academia. Donna Tartt, masterful writer she is, sucks you into the dark & moody New England campus of Hampden College located in a secluded small town in Vermont. You will be convinced to join her well-dressed alcoholic cult of pretension.

Keep reading

You will feel the need to wake up at 5am to study Ancient Greek and translate Paradise Lost into Latin. You may or may not feel the urge to murder one of your closest yet most annoying friends…this book truly has it all. And even if you’ve read this book with your eyes — this audiobook is a different experience entirely. Read by the author whose Mississippi accent has never dwindled…her voice is syrupy goodness.”

Cover of the The Violin Conspiracy audiobook by Brendan Slocumb
Best mystery without a body

The Violin Conspiracy

by Brendan Slocumb
Read by JD Jackson & Brendan SlocumbLength 12h 4m

“This was such an excellent mystery and it’s so refreshing reading a mystery that doesn’t involve a dead body. Here, we have a stolen, priceless violin. But most of all, we have Ray’s journey and his love of playing the violin.

Keep reading

Unsupported by his family, other than a loving grandmother, Ray, perseveres with his love of the violin, first playing on a crappy rental, to being gifted a family violin that was his great great grandfather’s, one of the formerly enslaved. The journey that Ray takes, isn’t easy, from lack of resources, gatekeeping and outright racism, until a professor sees and then nurtures his talent, culminating in a world renowned competition. All this, plus an engaging mystery as well as a fantastic narrator, makes this a must listen.”

Cover of the Things in Jars audiobook by Jess Kidd
Best Victorian mystery

Things in Jars

by Jess Kidd
Read by Jacqueline MilneLength 11h 29m

“Set in Victorian England, Things in Jars feels like a Sherlock Holmes story, if Holmes had been a woman. You can’t help but love Bridie Devine, a strong-willed, chain-smoking woman who has clawed her way from life as an orphaned thief to a highly sought-after detective often consulted by Scotland Yard.

Keep reading

Bridie’s newest case, though, is proving difficult and incredibly strange. Not only will it force her to confront someone from her past who she thought was dead, she’ll also team up with an actual ghost as she solves a fantastical crime. Highly imaginative, Things in Jars is a fun and immersive read.”

Mystery audiobook questions

Which mystery audiobooks are good for Agatha Christie fans?

And Then There Were None is the Christie classic, read by Hugh Fraser and just 5h 36m long. Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel is a new Lucy Foley mystery that brings back Miss Marple, and a bookseller compares The Golden Spoon to Christie meets The Great British Baking Show.

What are the funniest mystery audiobooks?

Vera Wong’s Unsolicited Advice for Murderers, Finlay Donovan Is Killing It, We Solve Murders and Everyone on This Train Is a Suspect all come with laughs. For more of the same, see our cozy mystery audiobooks.

Which mystery audiobooks are good for true crime fans?

Listen for the Lie is built around a podcast, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder has interviews that sound like a true-crime documentary, and The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels is told through transcripts and messages. For the real thing, see our true crime audiobooks.

What are the shortest mystery audiobooks on this list?

And Then There Were None (5h 36m), Everyone on This Train Is a Suspect (8h 27m), The Golden Spoon (8h 37m), The Villa (8h 38m) and The Woman in the Library (8h 58m).

Which mystery audiobooks have a full cast?

The Golden Spoon, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, The Guest List, Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel and The Mysterious Case of the Alperton Angels each have five or more narrators. For more, see our best full cast audiobooks.

What are the newest mystery audiobooks here?

Miss Wolcott’s Ghost (October 2026), read by Alfred Molina, and Murder at the Grand Alpine Hotel (September 2026) are the most recent.

More audiobook recommendations

Never run out of audiobooks to listen to

One email a week: the best current audiobook deals and one editor’s pick.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *